This excerpt from Barry M. Bloom’s interview of Dodger manager Don Mattingly for MLB.com could fan the flames of Mattingly’s detractors.
MLB.com: You’re a guy who constantly analyzes himself. How do you evaluate the job you’ve done this year?
Mattingly: Here’s how at look at it: Are we losing because I’m making mistakes? I look at the baseball side of it. Sure, I’ve made some mistakes, but I’m not sitting here crushing us every day, costing us games. Then I look at it from the standpoint of, am I not getting my message through to the guys? Are we not playing the game the way I want it to be played? Are we not playing with the energy and urgency? I don’t go about it asking myself how I’m doing. I know my club is not playing well. But I feel like I’m doing fine the way I’m handling it.
Mattingly isn’t single-handedly costing the Dodgers games, but he might be downplaying the impact of some of his decisions. But in Mattingly’s defense, no, he’s not crushing the Dodgers.
There’s no mistaking that the discussion around Mattingly’s future has turned into a firestorm.
Joe Sheehan voiced this thought in a podcast appearance with Will Leitch of Sports on Earth recently, and I’m not sure I disagree with it. Baseball managers are really middle management. They have a role, but the buck just doesn’t stop with them. There’s no dismissing the responsibility of the front office to deliver the right players and for the players to deliver the right results.
Sheehan suggested that the time has really come to divide the manager’s job where necessary, to ensure that you have someone who can inspire and teach players and someone who can effectively execute in-game strategy and tactics. It’s the same notion that finds the head coach leading the team on the field but the offensive and/or defensive coordinators calling plays. In baseball, the bench coach could evolve to be more than, as Sheehan put it, “a drinking buddy.”
Previously on Dodger Thoughts: Will Don Mattingly make it back to Yankee Stadium as Dodger manager?
* * *
Scott Van Slyke has been put on the Dodger roster, with Elian Herrera returning to Albuquerque and Chad Billingsley going to the 60-day disabled list.
* * *
Anonymous
Pedro Guerrero’s scouting report from 1979, handwritten by Tony La Russa. http://scouts.baseballhall.org/report?reportid=05990&playerid=guerrpe01
Jon Weisman
Small sample size?
Michael Green
I am reminded of Jim Bouton’s line in a book he co-edited that used a quotation from Rocky Bridges: I Managed Good, But Boy Did They Play Bad. While that line applies in some ways to Donnie B. and in other ways not at all, the line I’m thinking of is a shot of Connie Mack holding his scorecard and Bouton said that Mack positioned his players with a scorecard but “today they use coaches.” Different managers long have taken different approaches, and whether they work depends on the players–Casey Stengel wasn’t necessarily that different in Brooklyn and Boston than he was with the Yankees, but there he had the horses and knew what to do with them; whether another manager could have won 10 pennants in 12 years with those teams, we can never know. The point is, the manager may have a big impact strategically, may have an impact on the team’s personality and readiness, or maybe both. Or maybe there’s Tom Seaver’s response to the question of what role Yogi Berra played in the Mets winning the 1973 pennant. He said, absolutely none.
Anonymous
If given a list of 10 people the Dodgers were considering for Managers with Mattingly on the list, I might pick Mattingly. I can’t say I want to change Managers until I see the alternatives.
Glad to see that the Dodgers thought Van Slyke only needed a three day refresher course in the outfield before bringing him up.
Anonymous
Are there 10 manager replacements that are more Dodger than not?
Karros
Scioscia
Hershisher
Valentine
Lopes
Roenicke
Cora
Anonymous
Against San Diego tonight, Tampa Bay’s Alex Cobb faced four batters. He struck them all out. And gave up a run.
Anonymous
Two stolen bases and a wild pitch?
Anonymous
4 wild pitches?
Linkmeister
Gameday link is hosed up. Here’s the correct one:
http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/gameday/?gid=2013_03_10_pitmlb_balmlb_1#gid=2013_05_10_miamlb_lanmlb_1&mode=gameday
Also, it’s on Prime Ticket’s Alternate channel:
http://losangeles.dodgers.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20130509&content_id=47078828&vkey=pr_la&c_id=la
Jon Weisman
Mine is fixed.
Linkmeister
Grins. Sooright! *
*http://www.tvacres.com/horses_quickdraw.htm
KT
Dodgers Lineup for tonight:
Crawford LF
Punto 3B
Gonzalez 1B
Kemp CF
Ethier RF
Ellis C
Schumaker 2B
Gordon SS
Magill P
KT
For those of you looking for the Dodgers game:
http://t.co/IIbVUFRmaf
KT
Here is another listing for TV tonight:
http://www.truebluela.com/2013/5/9/4316518/dodgers-marlins-tv-prime-ticket-alternate-channels
KT
There is the old Scrappy Mc Popup that we all know and love
Anonymous
Yes great catch by Skippy!!
KT
NICE Catch Shoe
Anonymous
Here we go . . . I hope!
KT
Come on Nicky
Anonymous
Punto should ‘bunto’…. :-)
KT
Good Eye Shredder
KT
GONZO!!!!
Anonymous
Agon!!!!!!!!!!
Anonymous
Good golly Miss Molly!
Linkmeister
Woohoo!
Anonymous
Those three batters are all recent imports . . . now let’s see about the “old-time” Dodgers!
Linkmeister
Did I hear Vinnie say Matt’s got an 8-game hitting streak going?
Anonymous
that’s what I heard as well. (and that’s what BR says).
Anonymous
BR should also say that Matty cannot lay off that slider down and away!
KT
AJ!!…2 feet below the top of the wall
Anonymous
Within the margin of error!
Anonymous
Get that verified by the AL umps!
Anonymous
24 outs to go!
Anonymous
good job Matty!
KT
Good inning Matt
KT
Time to pile it on Boys…Start it off Dee
Anonymous
Nice try Dee
Anonymous
I can’t work up any enthusiasm for Mattingly, but I wonder about the alternatives as well.
Anonymous
WBB! Cheers. Nice photo of???
PS I don’t blame Donnie B when we can’t even move a runner from 2B to 3B.
Anonymous
“A terrific struggle”…great line Vinny :)
KT
Carl!
KT
Thief!!
KT
SD just fell, Roxs are falling in the top of 9th 3-0…looks good for gain some ground back so far
Anonymous
Nice DP!!!
KT
Nice Play Gonzo!!
Anonymous
Good job Matty. Three shutout innings!!!!!
Anonymous
That was a great pitch!
Anonymous
Stop walking the leadoff man.
Anonymous
Not good Matty!
Anonymous
Come on Matty punch him out
Anonymous
Just off the plate :(
Anonymous
Good pitch Matty!
Anonymous
Skippy again!!!!
KT
Nice Skippy!!
Anonymous
Tying run coming up…Yikes
Anonymous
Bad call.
KT
Thanks Artie
Anonymous
I’m sure we all had the same thought. :(
KT
Just Joking…should have put a smiley face
Anonymous
Come on Matty you got him 2-2!!!
OK 3-2
Anonymous
Frustrating with the walks!
Anonymous
DANG!!!!!!!!@
Anonymous
What’s killing you?
Bases on balls!
Anonymous
That’s this team . . . if they get the runs, they give ’em back.
KT
Some fan could have traded that ball for some gear…Not smart to throw it back on the field
Anonymous
Fish gear?
KT
Stanton signed bat
Anonymous
73 pitches already.
Anonymous
Rough inning.
Anonymous
But at least we’re not losing.
KT
Slappy McPopup comes through for us
Anonymous
Tis a cruel sport this game of baseball.
But I love it.
Anonymous
Shake it off Matty!
But stop walking the leadoff man!
Anonymous
Or any others!
Anonymous
Its OK Matty! A 1-2-3 inning :)
KT
Okay that was close…Come on guys let’s scratch this inning
KT
Nice Juan!!
Anonymous
Our offense has disappeared!
KT
Carl!
KT
Let’s go Shredder
KT
What started off so well sure came to a screeching halt
KT
Ken Gurnick @kengurnick 2m
Zack Greinke said he expects to pitch for the Dodgers Wednesday
Anonymous
Woot!
KT
Come on Dee
KT
Come on Tim
Anonymous
Swinging for the fences.
KT
in play…wall gave
Anonymous
And so it goes.
Anonymous
The Revenge of Slappy McPopUp!
Anonymous
“Juan” for four hit two!
KT
Kings Win and Advance
KT
we really need to scratch here…Come on Matty Lead this team
KT
Nice Matty…Come on Dre you’re Due
KT
Good steal Matty!!
KT
Come on AJ…little more umph this time and put it over the wall
Anonymous
Let’s go, Dodgers, clap clap clap clap clap!
KT
AJ!!
Anonymous
Way to go, AJ!
KT
Come on Skippy
KT
Nice way to move up AJ
KT
Come on Dee…Bring AJ home
Anonymous
Up to you, Dee.
Anonymous
Dagnabit!
Anonymous
Paco for closer!
Anonymous
Love watching Paco pitch.
KT
me too
KT
Got 1, need at least 1 more but I’ll settle for 2 for a walk off in the 9th
9 ,1, 2…I think we can do this
KT
Outside
Anonymous
Horrible
KT
I think this ump just likes to do his called strike 3 motion…two bad calls this inning
Night all
Anonymous
“We have to win sometime, don’t we?” she repeats, plaintively.
Anonymous
Everybody ready for a double digit losing streak? I know I am. “Whole new blue” yep.
Anonymous
I’m kinda puzzled…..
….
All day long, I’ve heard various radio/tv people suggest that the Dodgers should ‘get well’ against this not-so-good Marlins club…..
….
Helloooooooo! :-)
….
Kinda reminds me of of that Seinfeld when George wears a hairpiece…
….
Elaine: So, you dumped a woman because she’s bald?
George: Yeah, so?
Elaine: You’re Baaaaaaaaaaald!
Anonymous
When you lose to a “not-so-good” club, what does that make you?
Anonymous
Worse.
Anonymous
The TRUE slogan: “Dodger Thoughts: Never More Needed”
Jon Weisman’s outlet for dealing psychologically with the Los Angeles Dodgers and baseball.
Anonymous
I was just thinking that myself. I’d be out of my mind without this site.
Anonymous
Amen.
Jon Weisman
NPUT