Dodger Thoughts

Jon Weisman's outlet for dealing psychologically with the Los Angeles Dodgers, baseball and life

Skyfall

Sky2

By Jon Weisman

The sky, like the game, didn’t know what color to be.

An afternoon that had been so bright and so cathartic turned into a night so humbling, so fast.

Retiring 16 batters in a row between solo home runs in the first and sixth innings, Clayton Kershaw was painting poetry. And the Dodger offense, put on edge again by another plunking by a St. Louis pitcher, responded gloriously, reaching base 13 of the 26 times they came to the plate against Cardinals ace Adam Wainwright, struggling from the first inning to his fifth and last, to build a 6-2 lead in Game 1 of the National League Division Series.

A.J. Ellis with hit after hit after hit, including a two-run home run. Matt Kemp with three hits. Yasiel Puig on base four times. Carl Crawford, Hanley Ramirez busting through with two hits apiece.

Then day turned into night, and blue turned into black.

* * *

Improbably, Kershaw started the top of the seventh by allowing four consecutive singles, all to center field, and St. Louis cut the Dodger advantage to 6-3 with the bases loaded. Pete Kozma struck out on three pitches, but John Jay singled in another run.

Don Mattingly made a visit to the mound, but it was a short one. At 99 pitches, Kershaw, arguably, was still the best pitcher for the situation, validated by his fanning pinch-hitter Oscar Taveras on three more pitches, his 10th strikeout of the game.

The next batter was Matt Carpenter.

The villain from Kershaw’s Waterloo at St. Louis last year, Carpenter had started tonight’s game 0 for 2 before going against type and patience and homering in the sixth inning on the first pitch he saw from Kershaw. But here in the seventh, it was virtually a rerun from 2013.

Foul, foul tip, foul. Two balls, and then two more fouls. It was all so sickening in its familiarity, you placed your faith that fate wouldn’t be so cliched as to allow the same outcome as last October.

Instead, Carpenter drilled Kershaw’s next pitch to no man’s land in deepest right-center field, clearing the bases and clearing out Kershaw.

The damage wasn’t done. Perversely validating the long leash Mattingly gave Kershaw — and I have no argument with it (except perhaps when Carpenter himself came up, but even then I still believed) — Pedro Baez entered, walked his first batter and then gave up a three-run homer to Matt Holliday.

St. Louis had eight runs in the seventh, the most the Dodgers had allowed in a postseason inning since the Cardinals scored nine in the second inning of Game 4 of the National League Championship Series in 1985.

Unbelievably, Kershaw was charged with more runs (eight) in this game than in last year’s finale, the most in MLB postseason history by a pitcher who had struck out at least 10 batters, surpassing Randy Johnson, who allowed seven while striking out 11 in Game 1 of the 1999 NLDS, 15 years ago Sunday.

* * *

In the bottom of the eighth, Adrian Gonzalez hit a two-run home run raised an eyebrow. Was the disaster ending of the seventh a false climax? Would the night end with fireworks shooting to the stratosphere?

One out into the ninth, Ellis singled and Andre Ethier doubled. Dee Gordon hit a grounder — bobbled by David Descalso, but not for long — to drive in the ninth run for the Dodgers. Was the greatest postseason game of Dodger Stadium history happening before our eyes?

Puig, larger-than-life Puig, came to the plate and battled like a maxi-Carpenter, fouling off three Trevor Rosenthal pitches of 99 mph or faster with a 1-2 count. It was heart-pounding.

And then it was over.

* * *

We want our team to win, why? If we’re not in the game, if we’re only watching, we want to win for the way it makes us feel. It’s emotional rescue, served at your pleasure.

The joy that comes with a victory has as much to do with the endorphins (or whatever’s the correct term — sue me, I’m not a biologist) they generate as any other tangible quality. The rush, multiplied by the stakes, is incredible.

The absence of that joy, the deprivation, is what you get when you’re not in the playoffs. The reversal of that joy, into what came tonight, creeping shadows into your soul darker than those harmless silhouettes on the field before the sun set, tests your very spirit.

But until there are no more games, you don’t stop. You keep coming back for more. And Saturday brings another game. A new sky.

Previous

Renewing the cycle of insanity

Next

Kershaw: ‘It’s an awful feeling to let your teammates down’

12 Comments

  1. Jon, I love you, but if Clayton Kershaw has given up four straight hits, he is not arguably the best pitcher the Dodgers have to offer in that situation. The best post-season manager I ever saw was a manager whose strategic abilities I long questioned: Tommy Lasorda. Mattingly handled that situation like it was the regular season. It isn’t, but he apparently doesn’t know that.

    • Jon Weisman

      Well, I disagree, so I guess “arguably” he is. Only when Carpenter came up did I have doubts. Not before.

      • Agree – Kershaw’s strength is getting out the tough situations. He’s done it all year. Somehow Carpenter sees the ball well and was very (too) comfortable during that at bat – just like last year.

      • If I conceded that point, then I would also have to ask why he pitched to Carpenter. Now, maybe I missed it, but I don’t recall seeing anybody go to the mound during that sequence. If you consider Kershaw’s lifetime record against the Cardinals isn’t up to his usual level, what happened last year against the Cardinals, and that this is the first of the best of five where the home field advantage is at issue, and if I am right that nobody went to the mound to see what was up before that, I want to know who fell asleep or decided that since Kershaw has never allowed a run before, he wasn’t going to now. Sorry, Jon, I am a fan, and I want my guys to win, and I don’t sit around questioning whether they put forth their best effort; I also have defended Mattingly in a lot of places. Not tonight. While I don’t think this would have been good managing during the regular season, it is especially egregious in the post-season.

      • Jon Weisman

        “Now, maybe I missed it, but I don’t recall seeing anybody go to the mound during that sequence.”

        Mattingly went to the mound about two batters before Carpenter.

  2. (Trying to get some perspective on this) – 51 years a Dodger fan – this is the worst game of all time. Yeah there have been other horrific experiences (2 drop fly balls in the 66′ series, the Jack Clark and Ozzie Smith home runs, the 3 Reggie home runs) but all of those games at least could have gone either way. This game was over – or it should have been. I can’t even blame Mattingly, he went with his best and it wasn’t enough. I don’t it I don’t have much hope, baseball history doesn’t bode well for teams that loose big like this.

    • Jon Weisman

      As attempts to get perspective go, I’m not sure you succeeded, but let’s hope for the best going forward.

  3. Dodgers showed heart tonight. I’m pessimistic by nature, but the almost comeback showed me something that boosts my spirits moving forward.

    Maybe my heart will feel better in the morning and even better this time tomorrow. Go Dodgers!

  4. I’m keeping a stiff upper lip. Tomorrow is another game, a must win, but still another game. BTW as we speak I am still wearing my kid K jersey. Life is beautiful…good night everyone :)

  5. oldbrooklynfan

    Yes, I agree, a new sky. A new game also. No one knows what the outcome will be but I got a feeling that it won’t be the same as Friday night’s game. What I’m saying is the beauty of sports is that there are no two games alike. Because we lost this game, doesn’t mean we’re going to lose tonight.

  6. Jon, I can’t seem to reply to your correction, which I appreciate, and I had forgotten that he went to the mound THEN. Unfortunately, he should have been out there much sooner, or Honeycutt should have been, because after three straight hits, something obviously was wrong. They weren’t infield dribblers and there was no botched defense to change the result. I’d like to cite something from our team’s glorious and not so glorious past: the Mickey Owen play in 1941. After that game, Leo Durocher said, “Blame ME.” He said after the pitch got away and Henrich went to first, it was his job as manager to get to the mound and say, it’s ok, we still have two out, let’s just settle down. That is what should have happened.

  7. Sorry, in the postseason, with his history, and having given up four hits, he’s not the best pitcher. I don’t care who it is but it’s not him. This is ridiculous.

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén